Can You Put a New Roof Over an Old Roof

When you notice problems with your roof or when it is nearing the end of its life, it’s time to make some important decisions. Can you put a new roof over an old roof? You may be wondering about the available roofing options and which one would work best for you. In this case, calling a professional roofing contractor is a wise move. They can discuss your options and guide you in the right direction.

If your roof is in a condition where only a few small repairs are needed to bring it back to life, and it doesn’t require a complete replacement, reroofing might be a good option to consider. Reroofing involves installing a new roof on top of the existing one. It’s important to note that reroofing is different from roof replacement, as it has specific requirements that your roof must meet.

Now, let’s delve into the details of reroofing. By reading further, you will not only learn about the process itself but also discover its major advantages and how it differs from other roofing methods.

Roof Replacement vs. Reroofing

Overlaying or reroofing an existing roof are other terms for this process. Roofers will install a brand new roof on top of your old one. The old roof is not torn off, but a new layer is added. This process is only possible once, as you are only allowed to have two layers on your roof.

The process of replacing a roof involves tearing off the old one. Roofers remove everything, including the deck, to start anew with the new roof. This includes installing felt paper and shingles. Roof replacement involves tearing off everything, so it is possible to do this on any roof.

Roof replacement is more costly than reroofing because it requires more time and effort. If your roof is not damaged but is just old and no longer functional, then reroofing is a good solution. It involves less work, less money, and less time.

Why and When Should You Replace an Old Roof?

If your roof is failing but still in good overall condition, you may want to consider re-roofing. Your roof has reached the end of its life, but its sheathing and underlying structure are still in good condition. It’s possible that your shingles are losing granules or are worn due to weather or age, but they are not causing any leaks. They are also not curled or missing. All of these are good reasons to install a new layer over the existing shingle.

By adding another layer of quality shingles, you are adding a protective layer to your roofing system. The original shingles will be protected by the underlayment and roof deck. This layer serves as an upgrade or even a revitalization of your roof, which enhances your leak protection. It helps direct water away from your roof and into your gutters and drains to prevent pooling.

You can also opt for re-roofing when you want to make a change. For example, you might want to switch up the color or design of your roof. Or you might be renovating your house and want the roof to complement your new style. Even if you don’t wish to redesign your roof, the aesthetic appeal will still be improved. The new layer of shingles gives the roof a more three-dimensional look and depth.

It’s clear that re-roofing is a more cost-effective option than a full roof replacement. This is because there’s no need to tear off the old roof, including the shingles and the underlying structures. It also means there will be less time and labor involved in the project, resulting in lower costs. The roofer can start the roof installation immediately, as there’s no need to spend time removing and disposing of shingles.

When Is Reroofing Not a Good Idea?

Professional and honest roofers will always inform you if your roof isn’t suitable for re-roofing or overlay. A roofing inspection should be conducted before any work begins.

After a thorough roof inspection, a roofer will provide you with a report or recommendation. They will explain why re-roofing your roof is necessary. It’s advisable to request multiple roof estimates to ensure you’re making the right decision.

One clear reason why an overlay cannot be done is if you have asphalt shingles. You can only install shingles on top of existing shingles to create a new roof. Mixing materials is not allowed, and you also cannot install a new roof over wood or slate tiles.

Curled shingles are another hindrance, as you cannot install a second layer until the first layer is flat and level. If you want to re-roof your home, it’s important to first identify the cause of the curling.

If you’ve already replaced your roof twice, adding another layer of shingles is not an option. It could make the roof too heavy. If your roof exhibits visible and extensive damage, adding another layer should not be considered. Instead, everything should be removed, and the underlying problem should be addressed.

Final Thoughts – Can You Put a New Roof Over an Old Roof?

Re-roofing presents an attractive option for individuals whose roofs do not require complete replacement but are aging or experiencing reduced functionality. It proves to be a cost-effective and time-saving alternative to full roof replacement, as it avoids the need to remove the existing roof.

To make an informed decision, it is advisable to consult a reputable roofer. They can conduct a thorough roof inspection, offer an accurate estimate, and provide valuable guidance on the best course of action for your specific needs.

Trust us to transform your roof into a masterpiece that will stand the test of time. Contact All Star Roofing today and let us elevate your home to new heights of elegance and durability. Experience the difference with All Star Roofing – where every roof tells a unique story.

Reroofing FAQs

Can You Put a New Roof Over an Old Roof?

It is possible to place a new roof on top of an existing one, but specific requirements must be met for reroofing to be an option. The roof’s underlying structure and sheathing must be in good condition. Shingles should not be missing or causing leaks, and they should not have curled edges, as a new layer can only be installed if the previous layer is perfectly flat and level.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Reroofing?

The advantages and disadvantages of re-roofing existing shingles are a subject of debate among roofing professionals and homeowners.

The two primary advantages of reroofing are cost and convenience, as you don’t need to remove the entire roof. Additionally, your new roof can be installed much faster compared to a complete roof replacement.

The main drawback of reroofing is that it’s not suitable for every roof. The weight of the additional layer of shingles makes it impossible to re-roof more than once.

For How Long Does a Roof Overlay Last?

Roof overlays can last up to 15 years if certain conditions are met. These conditions include having a roof in good condition and not too old, as well as proper installation of the overlay.

Does It Make Sense to Put a New Roof Over an Old Roof?

The critical question at hand is whether the old roof should be removed entirely or if a new layer should be added to facilitate the roof replacement process. As previously mentioned, reroofing presents an excellent alternative to full roof replacements, provided your roof is suitable for an overlay. However, it’s important to note that if your roof is not suitable for reroofing, attempting it can lead to more harm than benefit.

Other Services We Offer


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *